N NARRISTOTLE™THE GADFLY GAZETTE

Contrarian Craft · 2 min read · By Narristotle

The Outline Is Not the Story

Zach Cregger doesn’t outline. That’s the headline, and half the internet treated it like a permission slip. The other half treated it like a threat.

THE SHORT ANSWER

Zach Cregger doesn’t outline. Fincher and Tarantino cut a 230-page script down to size. Both methods work, which tells you the outline was never the point.

Zach Cregger doesn’t outline. That’s the headline, and half the internet treated it like a permission slip. The other half treated it like a threat.

The same week, Fincher and Tarantino took a 230-page script and cut it down. Two opposite methods. Both ended with a movie. The outline was never the point. The point was knowing what the story was about before the camera rolled, or finding out by writing it badly first.

The conferences just ended. Bouchercon, Jackson Hole, Kauai. Everybody came home with a notebook full of ideas and a head full of other people’s sentences. Here is the unglamorous part nobody puts on a panel slide: most of those ideas die quietly by Thanksgiving. The ones that live are the ones somebody sits down and writes, badly, on a Tuesday.

So pick your poison. Outline if it steadies your hand. Skip it if it bores you into quitting. What you cannot skip is the draft. A plan is not a page. A page is a page.

The Method says the same thing in fancier clothes: structure is a tool for finding the turn, not a fence around the story. Try it both ways on the same scene sometime. Write it from an outline, then write it cold. Keep the one that surprises you.

The takeaway: The outline was never the point. The draft is. A plan is not a page, and a page is a page. — See the Method.

Bring the idea. Even the messy version.

Your notes, your voice, your story. Let’s get to the draft.

Explore RoughDraft Maker →